Formulas for heroes in the iliad and in beowulf jstor. As it is always easier for my interest to be held, when i am watching something instead of reading it. Although grendels feelings are portrayed as remorseful and the reader gives more sympathy towards his actions, he is still committing the same crimes in both readings. Each hero, however, had one extremely close friend, and the death of that friend pushed him over the edge. Beowulf and the iliad comparison essay summarystory. Comparison of achilles from the illiad and beowulf from beowulf. Both the iliad and the aeneid are classics in epic poetry. They are considered two of the most influential early works in western literature.
Comparing and contrasting beowulf and achilles both beowulf and achilles are poetic characters, who hail from different eras of history and. Achilles and gilgamesh were both involved in many battles, as detailed in homers iliad and the mesopotamian epic of gilgamesh, respectively. Thesis statement on differences between beowulf and achilles. In the movie briseis comes from lyrnessus, and is captured by the aecheans before the siege of troy. The similarities between achilles and hector is that both lived in the present moment and both wanted to achieve glory in order to be the hero that their homeland needed, while the differences include achilles being stubborn and angry while hector was prideful, yet cowardly and impulsive. Achilles vs beowulf compare and contrast essay 1150 words. Akeem brooks english 4b4 october 8, 20 beowulf the movie and book comparison in the movie and poem beowulf there were many differences and similarities that stood out. Get an answer for compare and contrast beowulf and achilles. One difference between the poem and the movie was that the poem explained the actual story of beowulf and his journey in much more detail.
In the book the iliad we saw so many warriors and a lot of them though that they were greats warrior but when achilles appeared the difference is completely big and is the same thing in the beowulfs poem these two characters had the strong of hundreds of warriors what help them to make amazing exploits like to kill monster or to kill an army without help. Although achilles and hector seem very similar, they actually have a lot of differences between the two of them, which makes each of. Compare and contrast beowulf and the iliad answers. Achilles, on the other hand, is not as heroic as beowulf, even thought he was also a great warrior and had superhuman strength, he mostly fought for revenge, social position, and power. Epic of gilgamesh and enkidu with achilles and patroclus, beowulf and hrothgar. Beowulfs kingdom the dragon beowulf 1999 christopher lambert beowulf and grendel 2005 grendel tv movie series scifi beowulf 2007 treasure craze or. The iliad begins in the 9th twelvemonth of the 10 twelvemonth besieging of the greeks upon troy. He went to war for the fame and glory, more than the cause.
Differences between beowulf and achilles essay by livingdeadgurl87, high school, 12th grade, a, april 2006 download word file, 1 pages download word file, 1 pages 0. The statue of wounded achilles at princeton university depicts the hero as weakened, and turned away. Similarities and differences between odysseus and achilles. Thesis statement on differences between beowulf and.
Beowulf was being a help by contributing his talents with the defeating of grendel. They both showed toughness and fearlessness in their roles, but their reactions to the death of loved ones differed greatly. Beowulf s characteristics show that he is a dominantly phlegmatic warrior that fluxes slightly in sanguine qualities during battle because he is mostly calm, rational, and confident. Themes and moral lessons end beowulf and achilles were both larger than life, they both traveled far distances so they could fight battles against fierce opponents who have never been defeated before. The iliad, written by homer, is about a few weeks of a tenyear war between the trojans and the acheans. Compare and contrast achilles vs beowulf the way of the warriors achilles and beowulf were two characters that had an amazing power that made his name lives for hundreds of years. I am sorry, but i do not know beowulf s actual status when he fights grendel, but he does not become a king until later in the story. They both have some of the same traits and they both have been through some of the same journeys. Alex kane february 7, 2009 honors english iv 2nd period ms. They fought for honor, glory and immortality so they would both be remembered. So this essay is about beowulf and achilles and what they went through to be famous and also what they went through to keep their fame. The wrote the book from a male perspective, for a target audience largely composed of male, and it features male characters apart from a few women.
Both the writings pursue heroism, war, glory and love, amidst the influence and authority of supernatural powers. What are some similarities and differences between beowulf and achilles. Grendels mother is a female character who has been given real power. Compare and contrast achilles vs beowulf the way of the warriors achilles and beowulf were two characters that had an amazing power that made. The movie and the poem influences of beowulf on film. Comparison between beowulf the epic and beowulf the film free. Parallels between virgils aeneid and homers iliad and. Bellinis statue of aeneas depicts the demigod as strong and unafraid, and bearing anchises on his shoulder.
Essay about achilles vs beowulf compare and contrast 1165 words. A tale of two heroes the story of beowulf and the story of achilles are both epic stories that involve heroic narratives and have mythic potencies. Another difference between them is that beowulf was fighting to help save the danes and achilles was fighting hector for revenge because he had killed his friend. The film presents rites of greek polytheism, including libation, prayer and charons obol anachronistically, since coinage comes into use only 600 years later, but. Similarities and differences between beowulf and achilles 1104 words 5 pages achilles and beowulf both were born of high importance and were known throughout the lands. What are the differences and similarities between achilles. Essay about achilles vs beowulf compare and contrast. Essay on compare and contrast between achilles and hector. Compare and contrast beowulf and achilles 1966 words bartleby. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and the movie troy essay sample. How do achilles and gilgamesh compare as epic heroes. As grendel is trying to flee heorot, beowulf slams the door on his arm, severing it.
It was interesting to be able to visually see the poem come to life. Main differences between the original greek myth and the film according to the myths, zeus, athena, apollo, hera, aphrodite and poseidon all played active parts in the trojan war. The differences between selfish achilles and selfless aeneas are immortalized in art and literature. And thats how id compare and contrast beowulf and achilles. Beowulf vs achilles essaysthe qualities of the main characters in both the iliad and beowulf are very similar. Similarly, aeneas was told by the ghost of hector in book ii that he was to leave burning troy to found a new city. However, there are some significant differences between one culture and the other. Beowulf was written in the estimated early eighth century in denmark, while the iliad achilles tale was written by homer many millennia ago in ancient greece. Beowulf is the focal point of the anglosaxon epic poem that bears his name, whereas achilles is the focal point of homers iliad.
The comparison between achilles and odysseus according to john miles foleys a companion to ancient epic 77, a comparison between achilles and odysseus is vital in understanding not only greek epic, but also the concept of a hero and his relationship to his community in a specific historical time and place foley 77. Beowulf is a great warrior and leader who fought to protect his. Although achilles and hector seem very similar, they actually have a lot of differences between the two of them, which makes each of them unique tags. Beowulf is a classical epic poem which describes beowulfs heroic deeds and his acts towards bringing justice and peace to the scandinavian society by eradicating grendel. Briseis is a trojan priestess and hectors cousin, captured during the attack on apollos temple. Both are great warriors and share a lot of characteristics, but they also have numerous differences that make them better or worse. Achilles was arrogant too but the difference between beowulf and. Beowulf was a legend and the town wrote a song in memory of him. Beowulf went on journeys because he wanted to show people that he is a reliable leader and that he can fight pretty much. Beowulf and achilles both have enemies that they face off against. Who would win in a duel between achilles and beowulf. Virgil used several characteristics associated with epic poetry, more specifically homers epics, including the use of hexameter verse, book division, lists of genealogies and underlying themes to draw parallels. Achilles and gilgamesh were extremely different with regards to who they were and how they responded to death.
Differences between beowulf and achilles writework. What are some similarities that king arthur, gilgamesh, beowulf, and achilles share. Similarities between beowulf and achilles 1041 words 123 help. Achilles was the greatest warrior in homers book the iliad, whereas beowulf proves his astounding strength and agility in the anglosaxon story beowulf. When writing the aeneid, virgil or vergil drew from his studies on the homeric epics of the iliad and the odyssey to help him create a national epic poem for the roman people. Arrogance is an important trait of any epic hero, in the film this arrogance is established in beowulfs tale of swimming in the ocean during which he states he slew several sea monsters, however in the background his followers can be seen stating that the original number. Achilles seems more like he does it because its expected of him because of his godlike abilities. Beowulf friend because he was always there for beowulf. Beowulf is a great warrior and leader who fought to protect his soldiers and to make places more peaceful.
Achilles was the son of peleus and the nereid thetis. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and. Compare and contrast the characters of beowulf and achilles. Achilles was known to be arrogant while gilgamesh was seen as ruthless. Beowulf and achilles fought for two different reasons. Achilles is the best warrior of the achaeans and hector was the top warrior for the trojans. Between the book and the movie there are a wealth of differences. Agamemnon is inspired to attack troy by a dream sent by the gods, who want to bring his army misery for taking briseis away from achilles. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Comparing the characters of beowulf and achilles 1291 words. Theres an rpg system ive seen called adventurer conqueror king, with an interesting way of comparing old heroes across times and fictions based on demographics.
A comparison between beowulf and achilles from the two great novels the. Epic of gilgamesh and enkidu with achilles and patroclus. Nov 08, 2012 achilles was the greatest warrior in homers book the iliad, whereas beowulf proves his astounding strength and agility in the anglosaxon story beowulf. Differences between the aeneid and the iliad in epic. The poems are interconnected and have strong similarities, even though the message and perspectives in each are different. Achilles vs beowulf compare and contrast freebooksummary. Young he fought for fame old he fought for the people. Examine the similarities and the differences between homers iliad and odyssey the iliad and the odyssey are ancient greek epic poems, traditionally ascribed to homer. Both texts provide clues as to what was considered the epic hero and reflect common belief systems. The iliad and the odyssey analysis essay blog essayshark.
Achilles was a little more vain than beowulf, but both of them enjoyed the glories of fighting. Achilles was a warrior and gilgamesh was a king, each wellrespected and feared in his role. Great warriors need some to have some specific characteristics to reach their fame because we have seem in some heroes that they have gods strong, a unique way to be. In my opinion beowulf is more courageous because he would do just about anything to protect his people and that he is not afraid of anything. Achilles is one of the main characters of the iliad and he is a great man. Beowulf and achilles are both powerful royal males who are the subjects of important epic poems. Similarities and differences between beowulf and achilles. He also perfectly embodies the values of loyalty, pride, and courtesy. Both of beowulf in anglosaxon literature and achilles in the iliad have a number of parallels in the way that they are presented as being the epic heroes and the leading characters with almost supernatural strength and the classical heroic traits. Odysseus and achilles are alike in so many different ways. To compare and contrast these two poets and their writing styles, i will use achilles battle with hector in homers iliad book 22 and compare it with achilles battle with cycnus in ovids metamorphoses book 12. Robert fitzgerald university press 1974 has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film troy 2004, wolfgang peterson. The comparison of these battles will give us a better understanding of these poets different views on the trojan war. This is particularly true of ancient epic poems such as beowulf and the iliad.
They participate in supernatural battles which most. Achilles had a unique kind to be it was similar to the kind to be of beowulf but it was not equal. Mar 26, 2019 examine the similarities and the differences between homers iliad and odyssey the iliad and the odyssey are ancient greek epic poems, traditionally ascribed to homer. Free essays on compare and contrast beowulf and achilles. An indepth analysis using humorism may explain the differences between ancient, classical, and medieval heroes such as achilles, aeneas, and beowulf because humors, elements, and the celestial bodies were all central concepts to their cultures understanding of the world and the temperaments of humans. Differences between beowulf and achilles free essay example. I am sorry, but i do not know beowulfs actual status when he fights grendel, but he does not become a king until later in the story. Compare and contrast beowulf and achilles 1966 words. Achilles was a greek and beowulf was a geat is also a difference between the two. A huge difference between he book and the movie was beowulfs relationship with grendels mother.
Beowulf wanted to be known for slaying terrible monsters, while achilles wanted to be known for being the one that would conquer troy. Beowulf and achilles are two wonderful examples of the differences and. The iliad and the odyssey are epic poems written by the greek poet homer around the 7th or 8th century b. However, despite their differences and the fact that they are fighting against each other on opposing armies, they also have numerous similar traits. The iliad describes the events of the trojan war, namely a few weeks of the last year of the war. Achilles vs beowulf compare and contrast study guides and book. Download thesis statement on differences between beowulf and achilles in our database or order an original thesis paper that will be written by one of our staff writers and. The most prominent similarity between the two is the characteristics granted to beowulf, the key trait being arrogance. Beowulf grapples grendel, who has a chain wrapped around his arm, pulling it loose. Achilles is a prince, since his father peleus is still alive.
Get an answer for compare and contrast the characters of beowulf and achilles in beowulf and the iliad. Comparison between beowulf the epic and beowulf the film. The events in the characters life do indeed cover a broad range of heroic epic encounters. Beowulf and achilles were characters that had gods strong but the strong that they had was very different because beowulf had a strong that could be comparable with the strong of so many warriors, but achilles strong also was incredible but it was not enough to compare with beowulfs strong, what achilles made to be a hero or a famous character. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad. Themes of gender beowulf is a male dominated piece of writing. Grendel in beowulf, grendel is seen as a villain because he goes around causing. He first learns about the mission of his life from a dreamwhere the voice of gods explained, the great make ready great walls. Sep 22, 2012 odysseus and achilles are alike in so many different ways. The protagonists in both epics, achilles and beowulf, participate in supernatural battles which most of the time determine the fate of their nation, their character traits reflect important. Jul 24, 2017 between the book and the movie there are a wealth of differences. Beowulf, the anglosaxon epic hero from the anonymously written beowulf, vastly differs from his ancient and classical predecessors, achilles and aeneas.
In comparison, many scholars see similarity especially characters, marital settings as well as wanderings throughout the mythological worlds and to semidivine mortals. Beowulf does not have the companion that achilles has patroclus. These two men have obvious differences in their approaches to fitting the mold of what a great warrior should be. However, there is a wide time margin between the formative and literary integrity of both the compositions. He also does that so people would find him as a reliable leader and wouldnt be afraid to be his followers. However both heroes exemplify the qualities most heroes attempt to exhibit. Differences between beowulf and achilles freebooksummary. Essay on compare and contrast between achilles and hector cram. The ancient legend of troy, recorded in homers epic poem the iliad oxford trans. Homers iliad and virgils aeneid, are two great legendary epics encompassing the formative years of greek and roman mythology. Compare and contrast beowulf book and movie free essay. An indepth analysis using humorism may explain the differences between ancient, classical, and medieval heroes such as achilles, aeneas, and beowulf because humors, elements, and the celestial bodies were all central concepts to their cultures understanding.
1443 37 1180 1437 1100 77 356 421 970 1649 833 1387 1179 1207 337 1506 1463 976 1554 521 930 499 350 1148 285 735 1505 85 1307 592 979 1078 383 33 1134 196 576 786 264 493 348